Climate Change Impact on Property Insurance: What Agents Need to Know

The homeowner insurance landscape is undergoing unprecedented upheaval as climate change alters risk profiles across the nation. Climate change is affecting the price of home insurance, with the average premium increasing by 21% last year. Insurance agents today face mounting challenges as rising costs, limited insurance availability, and increasingly frequent natural disasters reshape the property insurance market.

This article examines the critical ways in which climate change impacts home insurance, affecting both agents and their clients, providing essential insights into premium fluctuations, insurer withdrawal patterns, and emerging market solutions.

What Is Driving the Current Homeowner Insurance Crisis?

The insurance crisis stems from climate change factors fundamentally altering risk calculations. Last year, the U.S. had a record 28 disasters that cost more than a billion dollars in damage. Insurance companies respond to elevated risks by dramatically increasing premium rates or withdrawing from vulnerable markets entirely.

Key crisis drivers include:

• Intensified extreme weather events creating billion-dollar weather and climate disasters
• Traditional actuarial models are becoming obsolete as climate patterns shift unpredictably
• Insurance companies adopting conservative approaches, resulting in higher premium costs

These areas had a higher frequency of claims and severity of claims, about $24,000 on average, compared to an average of about $19,000 for the lowest-risk areas. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners has documented how climate change is impacting insurance availability nationwide, with some regions experiencing complete market failures.

How Are Rising Insurance Costs Affecting Different Geographic Markets?

Geographic location has become the primary determinant of insurance costs. From 2018 to 2022, consumers residing in the 20% of ZIP codes with the highest expected annual losses to buildings from climate-related perils paid an average of $2,321 in premiums, 82% more than those in lower-risk areas.

Regional impact patterns include:

• Coastal and wildfire-prone areas experiencing 30-50% annual premium increases
• High-risk zones forcing clients toward state-run fair access to insurance requirements programs
• Insurance deserts emerging where coverage becomes prohibitively expensive or unavailable

Commercial buildings located (FEMA), based on their exposure to natural hazards, have seen a 31% increase in insurance costs year over year and a 108% increase over levels from five years ago. Agents must develop expertise in understanding localized market conditions and maintaining relationships with multiple insurer partners.

Why Are Insurance Companies Withdrawing from High-Risk Areas?

Private insurers strategically retreat from markets where climate risk exceeds their risk tolerance. The fundamental business model relies on spreading risk across large pools; however, climate change creates concentration risks that challenge this approach.

Withdrawal patterns typically follow predictable sequences:

• Insurers stop writing new policies in high-risk areas
• Non-renewal of existing homeowner policies as they expire
• Complete cessation of operations in severely impacted regions

When state insurance regulators limit rate increases, insurance companies often choose market withdrawal over sustained losses. This creates cycles where remaining insurers face increased pressure, leading to further market consolidation and reduced competition.

What Role Do Wildfires and Natural Disasters Play in Premium Calculations?

Wildfire risk dominates homeowner insurance pricing, particularly in western states where fire seasons extend year-round with unprecedented intensity. Modern wildfire events can destroy thousands of homes in a single incident, resulting in catastrophic losses that fundamentally alter insurer risk models.

Natural disasters in 2024 - an extremely costly year for the insurance industry, with US$140 billion in insured losses. Since 1980, only two years have been more expensive, highlighting the profound impact of disasters on entire insurance markets.

Insurance companies now use sophisticated climate risk modeling, incorporating:

• Projected future conditions rather than historical data only
• Changing precipitation patterns and increasing storm intensity
• Rising sea levels and compound risk scenarios affecting multiple perils simultaneously

How Can a Homeowner Find Insurance in Challenging Markets?

When private insurance coverage becomes unavailable, homeowner clients have several alternatives:

State-sponsored programs:

• FAIR plans or beach and windstorm associations provide basic coverage
• Typically offer less comprehensive coverage at higher costs than traditional policies

Alternative markets:

• Surplus lines market for difficult-to-place risks
• Parametric insurance products provide payouts based on specific weather conditions
• Peer-to-peer insurance platforms and community-based risk sharing

Risk mitigation strategies:

• Fire-resistant landscaping and upgraded roofing materials
• Smart home monitoring systems
• Property improvements that can convince insurance companies to provide coverage

What Are Emerging Solutions and Future Outlook?

The Department of the Treasury recognizes that climate change poses systemic risks to the insurance industry and the broader financial system. Key recommendations include establishing federal insurance backstops for extreme climate events and creating regional insurance pools to spread catastrophic risks.

First Street estimates that unrestricted, risk-based insurance pricing would result in a 29.4% increase in average insurance premiums nationwide by 2055. This projection includes current underpricing corrections and climate risk increases.

Innovation opportunities include:

• Enhanced climate risk disclosure and improved data sharing
• Usage-based insurance models using smart home technology
• Collaborative approaches between government and private industry
• Advanced catastrophe modeling and GIS mapping tools

How Should Agents Prepare for the Future?

Successful insurance agents must develop expertise in climate science and risk assessment. Professional development should focus on emerging coverage types, alternative risk transfer mechanisms, and risk mitigation strategies, helping clients maintain insurability.

Essential preparation steps:

1. Understanding regional climate projections and building science developments
2. Maintaining relationships with multiple insurer partners serving different risk profiles
3. Building referral networks with risk management consultants and climate adaptation specialists
4. Developing expertise in surplus lines carriers and state insurance programs

Key Takeaways

• Climate change has fundamentally altered the property insurance market, leading to rising premium costs and a reduced availability of insurance.
• Illinois experienced the second-highest premium increases in the nation from 2021 to 2024, rising approximately 50% to an average of $2,942, indicating a widespread impact.
• Geographic risk concentration drives insurer withdrawal, forcing agents to understand alternative coverage options.
• Wildfires and natural disasters now dominate premium calculations, requiring a sophisticated understanding of risk assessment.
• Alternative coverage options, including parametric insurance and state programs, provide solutions for challenging markets.
• Professional development in climate science and alternative coverage options is essential for agent competitiveness.

About FastrackCE

Are you an insurance professional who needs to complete your insurance continuing education but doesn’t have the time? FastrackCE can help you get all your life and health and property and casualty continuing education credits done in one place and at your convenience. We offer online insurance continuing education courses in most states, covering a broad range of topics including most of the state-mandated courses such as ethics, flood, long-term care, and annuity training.

Sources: U.S. Department of the Treasury, CNBC Home Insurance Report, NPR Climate Change Insurance Analysis, Brookings Institution Study.